5 records
| Common Name | County | Date | Observer(s) | Number | Comments | |
| 1 Creole Pearly-eye | Dare; Mainland | 2010-05-23 | J. Lewis | 1 | Alligator River NWR | |
| 2 Creole Pearly-eye | Dare; OBU | 2025-07-18 | Eric Mouillesseaux | 1 | Observed in the Kitty Hawk Woods Reserve iNat 299029698 | |
| 3 Creole Pearly-eye | Dare; OBU | 2017-09-11 | J. Shelton | 2 | Kitty Hawk Woods | |
| 4 Creole Pearly-eye | Dare; OBU | 1996-08-11 | HEL | 1 | worn, being eaten by dragonfly | |
| 5 Creole Pearly-eye | Dare; OBU | 1993-05-23 | HEL | 1 | Colington |